EXTRA CREDIT

Mr. Peters' Top 33 American History Films

(NOTE: Students should get their parents' permission before viewing any "R-rated" films.)

  • A film can be an alternative educational experience and highlight points covered by the curriculum.
  • Parents: Watch the movie with your children and briefly talk about its message. Often, just one or two comments will make the film a meaningful experience. Your family will grow closer as all of you learn about history, culture and people. You will gain some positive control over screen time.
Extra Credit Top 33 Movie List (Word Document)

(1) All the President's Men

This is the story of the role of the press and Washington Post reporters Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein in the Watergate scandal. The accuracy of the film approaches that of a documentary.

Why cover Watergate when there are so many other choices available? For one thing, Watergate must be regarded as an important turning point in American history—never again will Americans naively regard their political leaders as highly. So, the scandal in a sense destroyed much of our innocence, and pointed out the value of freedom of the press.

 

(2) Patton
The classical portrayal of Patton by George C. Scott. He was one of the most interesting figures of the World War II era and was instrumental in the victory of the United States. victory.
(3) The Right Stuff
This movie shows the recruitment, training, and space flights of the first U.S. astronauts. Although the specific dialogue and some minor events have been fictionalized, most incidents reported in the film occurred as shown. The movie is based on Tom Wolfe's excellent non-fiction book of the same name.
(4) Glory
The Civil War movie that chronicles the 54th Regiment of Massachusetts. This African American unit fought bravely in an effort to win freedom for themselves and all slaves. The final battle is heroic and poignant.
(5) Dances with Wolves
Dances With Wolves" is a tale of a white soldier's gradual adoption by a tribe of Indians. Left alone to guard a deserted outpost, the soldier quickly comes to realize his only support in the wilderness is the Native Americans surrounding him. He soon adopts their ways and becomes a key member of the tribe. Knowing it is hopeless, he returns to his people to help them see the Indians not as enemies but people with a valuable way of life. This movie is a tribute to the cause of diversity.
(6) Forrest Gump
The story follows the life of low Forrest Gump (Tom Hanks) and his meeting with the love of his life Jenny. The film chronicles his accidental experiences with some of the most important people and events in America from the late 1950's through the 1970's including a meeting with Elvis Presley, JFK, Lyndon Johnson, Richard Nixon, fighting in Vietnam, etc. The problem is that he doesn't realize the significance of his actions. Forrest becomes representative of the baby boomer generation having walked through life blindly.

(7) The Grapes of Wrath
Driven off their Oklahoma farm during the dust bowl days of the Great Depression, the Joad family loads its belongings into a truck and joins thousands of other dispossessed farmers in the trek to California.
(8) Twelve Angry Men
This movie depicts jury deliberations in a murder trial. They show the dynamics of jury deliberations: the anger, the false starts, the personality conflicts, the joint effort and the functioning of several minds together to ferret out the truth. In this case, the first vote is 11 to 1 to convict but it wouldn't stay that way!
(9) To Kill a Mockingbird
Atticus Finch, lawyer and single parent, is trying to raise his family in a small Southern town during the Great Depression. Appointed by the local judge to defend a black man accused of raping a white woman, he surprises the town by mounting a vigorous defense. Finch is probably the best male role model on film, loving and nurturing his children and treating all those around him with respect and consideration
(10) Tuskegee Airman
This film tells the story of WW II's "Tuskegee Airmen," the African-American 332nd Fighter Group of the Army Air Corps. The film accurately portrays the destruction of the racist myth that blacks could not fly complex modern fighters. We are shown Eleanor Roosevelt, First Lady of the U.S. and champion of the rights of minorities, supporting the experiment with black pilots.
(11) Judgement at Nuremberg
This movie is a fictionalized account of the war crimes trial of judges and prosecutors who served the Nazis. "Judgment at Nuremberg" depicts a watershed event: the first trials, based on principles of justice and international law, of the leaders of a country that waged aggressive war and committed crimes against humanity. The film is a gripping, searching and provocative look at the moral issues surrounding both the actions of the accused and the process of bringing them to justice. The film also explores the issue of whether ordinary Germans bore responsibility for the Holocaust.
(12) Ghosts of Mississippi
This film recounts the retrial and conviction of the assassin of civil rights leader Medgar Evers, some 30 years after the murder. Both his widow, Myrlie Evers, and Bobby DeLaughter, the prosecutor, served as consultants for the film. With a few exceptions discussed in the Learning Guide, the film is reasonably accurate. The film also shows Mississippi's change to a state with a functioning justice system. The movie describes the workings of the legal system, a widow's perseverance and crusade for justice, as well as a prosecutor's commitment to righting an old wrong.
(13) Amistad
In 1839 slaves held captive aboard the ship La Amistad revolted, took control of the vessel, and tried to sail it back to Africa. The ship was seized by an American frigate and taken to the U.S., setting off a controversy that pitted the courts against the President (Marin Van Buren) and raised the consciousness of the North about the evils of slavery. The La Amistad incident was a milestone in the development of the abolitionist movement.
(14) Truman (HBO film)
Harry S. Truman was the 33rd President of the United States. He presided over the final victory of the Allies in World War II, the beginning of the Cold War, the conversion from a war economy to a peacetime economy, and most of the Korean War.

(15) The Crucible
These films present Arthur Miller's play about the Salem witchcraft trials. The play and the films capture the sense of the late 1600s as well as the hysteria and injustice of the red scare of 1947 - 1956. They raise several important questions, including: 1) when a society feels threatened, how far should it go in imposing tests of loyalty and requiring proofs of faith in commonly held beliefs; 2) how does a society ensure justice and fairness when it believes that its fundamental beliefs are under attack; and 3) should a person, in order to avoid an undeserved punishment, admit to something he didn't do and cooperate in an unjust investigation in which innocent people will be hurt
(16) The Patriot
A compilation of true historical figures formed the basis for Mel Gibson's character in this film set during the American Revolution. It shows that not all colonists were committed to the war on ideological grounds.
(17) The Red Badge of Courage
This adaptation of Stephen Crane's classic novel follows the experience of a raw recruit to the Union Army through his first two days of battle.
(18) To Hell and Back
The true W.W.II story of Audie Murphy, the most decorated soldier in U.S. history. Based on the autobiography of Audie Murphy who stars as himself in the film.
(19) Apollo 13
True story of the moon-bound mission that developed severe trouble and the men that rescued it with skill and dedication.
(20) Knute Rockne All American
This is a romanticized Hollywood biography of Knute Rockne, possibly the most creative football coach of all time. Knute Rockne's Notre Dame football teams were the first in the nation to use the forward pass as a major offensive weapon. He also pioneered coordinated backfield movements, called "the shift," which are used to maximize the chance for large gains on running plays.

"Knute Rockne All American" will acquaint children with this innovative man and the view that college sports are a game subordinate to the important work of education: e.g., Knute Rockne never intervened with a teacher to get a higher grade for one of his players; if a player's grades were not good enough, he was off the team.

(21) Tora! Tora! Tora!

"Tora! Tora! Tora!" describes the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor, December 7, 1941, from both the Japanese and American points of view.

Historical accuracy stands as the biggest strength of Tora, Tora, Tora. Copious research went into the writing, and the ambitious project used two separate film crews to give both the American and the Japanese points of view for Pearl Harbor. If you suspect certain lines of dialogue don’t sound theatrical, there’s a good chance that those lines are kept in because they are historically accurate. In fact, when Martin Balsam balked at the “death wish” line his Admiral Kimmel character makes, director Richard Fleischer informed him that the dialogue would remain intact because the Admiral actually did describe a spent bullet by saying “Would have been merciful had it killed me.”

While there are some intriguing characters, this film focuses on presenting historical drama in an even-handed way, even switching us back and forth between the American and Japanese perspectives.

(22) Warm Springs (HBO film)
This film describes Franklin Roosevelt's struggle against the effects of polio and his leadership in the development of a convalescent community at Warm Springs, Georgia. It shows an important stage in the development of his character. The movie highlights the innovations, mostly psychological, in treatment for the disabled that Roosevelt pioneered at Warm Springs.

"Warm Springs" will: (1) acquaint students with the most important U.S. President of the 20th century; (2) demonstrate how FDR's disability helped strengthen his character and gave him empathy for the suffering of others; and (3) enhance learning about Roosevelt's policies to combat the Great Depression by suggesting interesting parallels between the New Deal and the therapeutic community that Roosevelt helped construct at Warm Springs. The film is well researched and in many respects historically accurate. Like all historical fiction it takes dramatic liberties by telescoping many events into one or mixing up the time sequence. However, with the two exceptions described below, the movie is a reasonably accurate portrayal of the events that occurred from 1921 to 1928. It shows how FDR tried and failed to regain the ability to walk but discovered something more valuable within himself.

(23) Gettysburg
The Union victory at Gettysburg is considered by many historians to be the turning point in the Civil War. This film is a recreation of the battle. The film makers consciously attempted to recreate events as they occurred and also to describe the tragedy of the Civil War. The film is based on the historical novel, The Killer Angels, by Michael Shaara.

Almost everything shown in this film conforms to the historical record, including Colonel Chamberlain's bayonet charge, Longstreet's objections to Lee's tactics, Lee's statement accepting blame for the defeat, etc.

(24) Midway
World War II, Pacific Theater: the Japanese follow their stunning victory at Pearl Harbor with a massive assault on Midway Island, a strategic U.S. outpost in the Pacific. But the U.S. Navy is ready ... and looking for revenge.

(25) Thirteen days
This movie tells the story of the Cuban Missile Crisis from inside the White House. "Thirteen Days" captures the sense and tension of the times and shows the wise leadership of President John F. Kennedy.
(26) Tucker - The Man and his Dream
After the Second World War, Preston Tucker tried to start a car company to challenge the big Detroit auto makers. His prototypes were impressive. Sleek cars with engineering innovations such as seat belts long before they were mandated by the Government, Tucker's cars generated a waive of excitement. However, the political muscle of the Big Four Automakers (General Motors, Ford, Chrysler, and American Motors) doomed his project. This film is the story of Tucker's efforts and ultimate failure.
(27) High Noon
In this Western an outlaw recently released from jail is on his way back to the town he had once terrorized. His gang has reassembled, waiting for him to arrive on the noon train. Will the people in the town band together to resist? Will the marshal, recently retired and scheduled to leave town that very day, resume his duties or keep to his plans to depart? If the marshal stays, who will back him?

This film teaches the meaning of courage, loyalty, leadership, and the responsibilities of friends and married couples to each other. By showing an example of a man who stood up to outlaws, the film criticizes those who gave the names of people with left-wing political views to the McCarthyites and the House Un-American Activities Committee during the red scare of the late 1940s and early 1950s. "High Noon" is one of the few Hollywood movies in which the film makers, fearing government persecution, disguised the political implications of the movie.

 

(28) The Last of the Mohicans

Daniel Day Lewis must be type cast as the American colonial guy (he also stars in The Crucible). But here he heroically represents the idealized American frontiersman in Michael Mann’s excellent adaptation of James Fenimore Cooper’s immortal novel, set during the French and Indian War in upstate New York.

Michael Mann’s lyrical adaptation of James Fenimore Cooper’s novel actually presents a good picture of what the French and Indian War was like, and foreshadows the coming American Revolution. Mann’s cinematic landscapes are always pretty to look at, and the battle scenes here are choreographed brutally and as realistically as the romanticized Cooper work can allow.

(29) Nixon
Although he's one of the most chronicled public figures of the 20th century, Richard Milhous Nixon remains an enigma to many, his decisions, motives and behavior often shrouded in mystery. With the ill-fated 1972 Watergate break-in and its tragic aftermath--culminating in the President's 1974 resignation--as its focus, NIXON examines its subject's complex life, including his difficult youth in Southern California and often troubled relationship with wife Pat. We also see Nixon's incredible political life, during which he held the offices of Congressman at age 33, Senator at 37, and Vice-President at 39, before losing the Presidential election in 1960 and the California gubernatorial race in 1962, making his startling comeback six years later to win two terms as President. With the inevitability of classical tragedy, Nixon's political career finally crumbles beneath the weight of his past, his ambitions, and his blindness to events just outside his often remarkable range of vision
(30) Sergeant York
This stirring biography of World War I hero Alvin York features Gary Cooper's Oscar-winning performance in the title role. Once a brawler in backwoods Tennessee, York finds religion thanks to a literal bolt from the blue; when America enters the war and York gets drafted, he puts aside his pacifism to defend democracy. His expert marksmanship and battlefield exploits turn him into the war's most decorated soldier.
(31) The Spirit of St. Louis
Biography of Charles Lindburgh from his days of precarious mail runs in aviation's infancy to his design of a small transatlantic plane and the vicissitudes of its takeoff and epochal flight from New York to Paris in 1927.

(32) Quiz Show
This film is a true story based on the rise and fall of an intellectual, Charles Van Doren, who became a celebrity in a rigged game show.
(33) The Wizard of OZ
"The Wizard of Oz" is a classic musical, beloved by children and their parents for generations. The film is perennially popular because it teaches several basic values and deals with many of the issues and fears that children must confront as they mature: The movie is an excellent example of the literary device of allegory. In addition, the book (and with a few corrections the movie) can be used to spice up classes covering the debate over U.S. monetary policy in the late 1800s. (Dorothy is misled to take the yellow brick road (the gold standard) but is taken home by the silver shoes (the ruby slippers are silver in the book); the cowardly lion is William Jennings Brian ... and there is more).